Fishers Island NY Hotels

Search among 42 available hotels and places to stay in Fishers Island from 50+ providers

Check-in
Tue, 24 Dec
-
Check-out
Wed, 25 Dec
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Check-in
Tue, 24 Dec
-
Check-out
Wed, 25 Dec
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Tue, 24 Dec
-
Check-out
Wed, 25 Dec
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
View map
1-42 out of 42
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
Places to stay near Fishers Island
8.4
Great164 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
Guests of the comfortable 3-star Hilton, placed 5 minutes' drive from Mystic Seaport Museum, can splash about in a heated pool and savor drinks in a lounge bar.
FromC$ 171 /nightSelect
8.2
Great134 reviews
Map
12.1 km from Fishers Island12.1 km from City Centre
Located a mere 5 minutes' stroll from Charles W. Morgan, the Quality Inn Mystic features a swimming pool and a fitness area.
FromC$ 113 /nightSelect
8.2
Great29 reviews
Map
15.9 km from Fishers Island15.9 km from City Centre
While staying at the Point 1 Resort & Motel you are invited to discover Watch Hill Lighthouse, set about a 10-minute drive away, or Bayview Fun Park, which is a 20-minute walk away.
FromC$ 323 /nightSelect
8.4
Great173 reviews
Map
13.0 km from Fishers Island13.0 km from City Centre
The smoke-free Holiday Inn New London, An Ihg New London with an indoor swimming pool is a 10-minute ride from Monte Cristo Cottage.
FromC$ 242 /nightSelect
8.4
Great590 reviews
Map
12.1 km from Fishers Island12.1 km from City Centre
Mystic River Bascule Bridge is approximately a 10-minute drive from the grand 2-star Spark By Hilton Mystic Groton that features an outdoor pool.
FromC$ 92 /nightSelect
8.2
Great99 reviews
Map
11.3 km from Fishers Island11.3 km from City Centre
Staying at the family-friendly Hampton Inn Groton/Mystic means you will be about a 25-minute stroll from Groton Bank Historic District, while enjoying a swimming pool onsite.
FromC$ 158 /nightSelect
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
10.8 km from Fishers Island10.8 km from City Centre
Set 15 minutes by car from Fort Trumbull State Park and Museum and a near a train station, the welcoming 4-star Mystic Marriott Hotel And Spa includes fitness classes, facials and massage therapy.
FromC$ 216 /nightSelect
8.2
Great146 reviews
Map
11.9 km from Fishers Island11.9 km from City Centre
Featuring fitness classes, entertainment activities and recreational facilities as well as a swimming pool, the traditional Hampton Inn & Suites is situated in the middle of Mystic.
FromC$ 158 /nightSelect
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
Featuring a swimming pool, the comfortable 3-star Residence Inn Mystic Groton lies in the shopping district of Mystic, within a 5-minute walk of Charles W. Morgan.
FromC$ 300 /nightSelect
8.2
Great61 reviews
Map
15.2 km from Fishers Island15.2 km from City Centre
Located around a 10-minute drive from Napatree Point, the smoke-free Pleasant View Inn Westerly features a swimming pool.
FromC$ 287 /nightSelect
8.4
Great137 reviews
Map
11.2 km from Fishers Island11.2 km from City Centre
The pet-friendly Hyatt Place offers spacious rooms and a swimming pool within a 10-minute drive of Mystic River Bascule Bridge.
FromC$ 163 /nightSelect
8.4
Great127 reviews
Map
9.0 km from Fishers Island9.0 km from City Centre
Located 5 minutes by car from Mystic River Bascule Bridge, the unique 3-star Inn At features a swimming pool.
FromC$ 113 /nightSelect
8.0
Great114 reviews
Map
12.5 km from Fishers Island12.5 km from City Centre
Situated near an oceanarium and restaurants, and about 10 minutes by car from Fort Trumbull State Park and Museum, the Super 8 By Wyndham includes 97 rooms within a 10-minute drive of Groton Bank Historic District.
FromC$ 67 /nightSelect
Inn
8.4
Great230 reviews
Map
8.8 km from Fishers Island8.8 km from City Centre
Rooms of the 3-star Taber Inn Mystic face the patio and there is also an indoor heated pool on the premises.
FromC$ 214 /nightSelect
8.4
Great243 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
Boasting a location about a 5-minute stroll from Olde Mistick Village, the Howard Johnson By Wyndham Mystic includes 77 rooms and a heated pool.
FromC$ 115 /nightSelect
8.2
Great76 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
Set in a business district, the quality 2-star Motel 6-Groton, Ct - Casinos Nearby Groton offers a Jacuzzi and an indoor pool.
FromC$ 103 /nightSelect
8.4
Great67 reviews
Map
9.3 km from Fishers Island9.3 km from City Centre
The Whaler'S Inn Mystic is situated in a shopping area, 59 minutes' drive from T.F. Green airport.
FromC$ 786 /nightSelect
8.2
Great100 reviews
Map
13.0 km from Fishers Island13.0 km from City Centre
Featuring fitness classes, spa therapy and entertainment activities, the 3-star Baymont By Wyndham Groton/Mystic in a historic neighbourhood is located nearly a 10-minute drive from The Hempsted Houses.
FromC$ 158 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good16 reviews
Map
14.0 km from Fishers Island14.0 km from City Centre
Mystic Museum of Art and Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration are located 4.9 km and 2.5 km from the House Of 1833 Bed And Breakfast respectively.
FromC$ 530 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good105 reviews
Map
9.7 km from Fishers Island9.7 km from City Centre
Bluff Point State Park is within a 5-minute drive of the Hilltop Express Inn and Groton Bank Historic District is approximately 10 minutes away by car.
FromC$ 142 /nightSelect
8.2
Great132 reviews
Map
11.8 km from Fishers Island11.8 km from City Centre
Boasting sauna facilities and an indoor pool, the 3-star River Hotel & Suites Mystic offers to take advantage of proximity to Olde Mistick Village Pond, located nearly a 15-minute walk away.
FromC$ 146 /nightSelect
8.4
Great45 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
Boasting an indoor swimming pool, the sophisticated Hilton Garden Inn Mystic/Groton is around 10 minutes by car from The Submarine Force Military Museum.
FromC$ 166 /nightSelect
8.4
Great49 reviews
Map
12.2 km from Fishers Island12.2 km from City Centre
Located in the old part of Groton, 10 minutes by car from Thames River Heritage Park, the Inn & Suites offers fitness classes, entertainment activities and barbecue.
FromC$ 113 /nightSelect
Bed & Breakfast
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
A buffet breakfast is served daily at the 3-star Whitehall Mansion Bed & Breakfast.
FromC$ 219 /nightSelect
8.0
Great186 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
Located in a touristic area of Mystic, the 2-star Rodeway Inn also has access to an outdoor pool.
FromC$ 86 /nightSelect
8.0
Great125 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
Dining at Indian restaurant with Indian dishes is available at the Ramada By Wyndham, set approximately 10 minutes' drive from Kiely Park.
FromC$ 73 /nightSelect
8.2
Great81 reviews
Map
11.4 km from Fishers Island11.4 km from City Centre
Situated in the shopping district of Mystic, the affordable 3-star Holiday Inn Express Mystic, An Ihg offers fitness classes and entertainment activities.
FromC$ 156 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good96 reviews
Map
12.2 km from Fishers Island12.2 km from City Centre
Featuring spa therapy and entertainment activities, the 2-star Econo Lodge Inn & Suites is about 10 minutes by car from Hygienic Art gallery as well as near a train station.
FromC$ 73 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good44 reviews
Map
11.9 km from Fishers Island11.9 km from City Centre
Within a 5-minute drive of Whaling Wall, the 2-star Rodeway Inn includes 50 rooms.
FromC$ 102 /nightSelect
7.6
Very good64 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park is about 5 minutes' drive from the Days Inn & Suites By Wyndham Groton Near The Casinos and Groton Shoppers Mart Shopping Center is 10 minutes away by car.
FromC$ 86 /nightSelect
8.0
Great147 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
Sitting a 10-minute drive from Bluff Point State Park, the lovely Flagship Inn & Suites Groton is located in the business district of Groton.
FromC$ 65 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good50 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
A 15-minute ride from Flying Horse Carousel, the 2-star Americas Best Value Inn - includes 30 rooms.
FromC$ 89 /nightSelect
8.2
Great37 reviews
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
At a 26 km distance from Avery Copp House, the 2-star Windsor includes 31 rooms.
FromC$ 79 /nightSelect
8.4
Great40 reviews
Map
16.0 km from Fishers Island16.0 km from City Centre
The 3-star Breezeway Resort Westerly overlooks the beach and boasts a location in a beach area.
FromC$ 1 175 /nightSelect
7.4
Very good2 reviews
Map
12.4 km from Fishers Island12.4 km from City Centre
The Thames Street Inn is set 5 minutes on foot from Missionary Church Of God in Christ and approximately a 10-minute ride from USS Nautilus.
Select
8.4
Great1 review
Map
15.9 km from Fishers Island15.9 km from City Centre
Overlooking ocean, the 3-star Sandy Shore Motel Westerly welcomes guests with an express breakfast.
Select
8.6
Great47 reviews
Map
15.8 km from Fishers Island15.8 km from City Centre
Set nearly a 10-minute ride from Watch Hill Historic District, the rooms in the smoke-free Hotel Maria have views of sea.
FromC$ 2 243 /nightSelect
8.2
Great25 reviews
Map
8.3 km from Fishers Island8.3 km from City Centre
The positioning of the Harbor View Landing in the very heart of Mystic ensures fast access to Hoxie Scenic Overlook, which is only 250 metres away.
FromC$ 429 /nightSelect
8.4
Great105 reviews
Map
12.0 km from Fishers Island12.0 km from City Centre
Select
Map
12.6 km from Fishers Island12.6 km from City Centre
Located 10 minutes by car from United States Coast Guard Museum, the 2-star Super 8 Groton features a continental breakfast.
FromC$ 198 /nightSelect
Map
12.3 km from Fishers Island12.3 km from City Centre
Select
Map
9.4 km from Fishers Island9.4 km from City Centre
Select

Where to stay in Fishers Island?

Best cheap hotels in Fishers Island

3 Bedroom Townhome Near Disney Sleeps 8 is an affordable choice with rates from only 180C$ per night. The top-rated economy hotel, American Sunshine Hampton Lakes, is a short drive to Affection Section and offers comfortable accommodations and budget rates from 168C$. There are many budget-conscious hotels and hostels in West Kissimmee district such as Glenbrook Executive Homes with rates from 196C$.

Luxury and boutique accommodation in Fishers Island

For the ultimate relaxing trip, book a room at the luxury 4-star American Sunshine Highlands Reserve.

Explore and find your best apartments, B&Bs and others

Consider staying in an apartment like 3 Bedroom Home Kitchen Sleeps 8 if you're looking for easy access to a variety of shopping facilities like stores and a grocery store and yet budget accomodation. Think about staying at 3 Bedroom Townhome With West Facing Splash Pool or 4 Bedroom Town Home In Emerald Island, if you'd like to take advantage of staying at B&B. Ocean Florida Villas is an affordable business hotel, less than a 10-minute drive to Gallery of Arts and History and is located 150 meters from Starbucks. For a relaxing vacation, book a resort hotel near Camp Disney, such as American Sunshine Disney Area Executive or Crystal Cove By Cozykey Vacation Rentals.

Show moreLess

Fishers Island hotels essential information

🏨 Hotels in Fishers Island 42
👛 Lowest price 65 CAD
✍️ Hotels Reviews 3 979