Shelter Island NY Hotels

  • Hotel list
  • Hotels on map
  • Sort by:
Legend
Legend
  • Hotels on page
  •  
  • Other hotels
  • Airports
  • Underground stations
  • Train stations
  • Parks
  • Tourist attractions
  • Museums
  • Convention centers
  • Stadiums
  • Food and meals
  • General

Hover above the icons to see hotel photo and details.

Click the hotel to go to the main hotel page.

  • 35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States, 11965 (Map)
    7.6 - Excellent
    Based on 21 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-36

    The charming Sunset Beach is a great place in a seaside... More details

    From
    C$627
    per night
    Book Now
  • 81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY, United States, 11964 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-52

    Featuring a spa center, an outdoor swimming pool and a... More details

    From
    C$389
    per night
    Book Now
  • Hotels near Shelter Island

  • 7 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY, United States, 11965 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-61
    1.9 km from Shelter Island

    Seven Shelter Island Guest House is a 2-star business... More details

    From
    C$433
    per night
    Book Now
  • 23 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY, United States, 11965 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-17
    2.2 km from Shelter Island

    The 4-star Chequit Inn is located in the heart of... More details

    Book Now
  • 300 Main Street , Greenport, NY, United States (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-10
    4.3 km from Shelter Island

    American Beech offers fine accommodation in Greenport. ... More details

    Book Now
  • 104 Bay Avenue, Greenport, NY, United States, 11944 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-56
    4.4 km from Shelter Island

    The unique Stirling House B&B Greenport is a 4-star... More details

    Book Now
  • 300 Main Street , Greenport, NY, United States (Map)
    Stirling Square Apartments pics,photos
    4.4 km from Shelter Island

    Stirling Square is an apartment in Greenport within... More details

    Book Now
  • 714 Main Street, Greenport, NY, United States, 11944 (Map)
    7.8 - Excellent
    Based on 4 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-36
    4.9 km from Shelter Island

    The 2-star Townsend Manor Inn boasts close proximity to... More details

    From
    C$339
    per night
    Book Now
  • 817 Main Street , Greenport, NY, United States (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-23
    5.1 km from Shelter Island

    Fordham House is a 3-star venue set just 30.8 km from... More details

    Book Now
  • 61475 Route 48, Greenport, NY, United States, 11944 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-42
    5.6 km from Shelter Island

    Cliffside Resort Condominiums - Greenport is placed in... More details

    From
    C$599
    per night
    Book Now
  • Heron Suites Southold

    3 star hotel
    61600 Main Road, Southold, NY, United States, 11791 (Map)
    8.4 - Exceptional
    Based on 13 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-36
    5.6 km from Shelter Island

    Heron Suites is a 3-star venue set just 4.6 km from... More details

    From
    C$146
    per night
    Book Now
  • 7850 Main Road, East Marion, NY, United States, 11939 (Map)
    8.0 - Excellent
    Based on 9 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-75
    6.2 km from Shelter Island

    The unique Blue Inn At North Fork is situated in the... More details

    From
    C$216
    per night
    Book Now
  • 8900 Main Road, East Marion, NY, United States, 11939 (Map)
    9.4 - Superb
    Based on 22 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-49
    6.5 km from Shelter Island

    Arbor View House Bed And Break is a 2-star venue set... More details

    From
    C$430
    per night
    Book Now
  • 54300 County Route 48 , Southold, NY, United States, 11971 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-36
    6.6 km from Shelter Island

    Shorecrest Bed And Breakfast is a 4-star venue set just... More details

    From
    C$429
    per night
    Book Now
  • 31 West Water Street, Sag Habor, NY, United States, 11963 (Map)
    6.6 - Good
    Based on 11 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-1
    8.1 km from Shelter Island

    Baron'S Cove Inn is placed in a shopping area of Sag... More details

    From
    C$817
    per night
    Book Now
  • 765 Rt 114, Sag Habor, NY, United States, 11963 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-22
    10.4 km from Shelter Island

    The quiet Forever Bungalows is a great place in a... More details

    From
    C$546
    per night
    Book Now
  • 1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY, United States, 11932 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-75
    14.8 km from Shelter Island

    Situated near Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum... More details

    From
    C$1 558
    per night
    Book Now
  • 2668 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY, United States, 11932 (Map)
    6.2 - Good
    Based on 3 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-23
    14.8 km from Shelter Island

    The comfortable Bridge Inn is a 2-star property set... More details

    From
    C$435
    per night
    Book Now
  • Bridgehampton Inn

    4 star hotel
    2266 Main St , Bridgehampton, NY, United States (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-14
    15.1 km from Shelter Island

    Bridgehampton Inn is a 4-star property only 7.2 km from... More details

    Book Now
  • 380 Inn Wainscott

    3 star hotel
    380 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott, NY, United States, 11975 (Map)
    7.2 - Very good
    Based on 6 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-36
    15.3 km from Shelter Island

    The deluxe 380 Inn is placed near by the beachfront.... More details

    From
    C$354
    per night
    Book Now
  • 207 Main Street, East Hampton, NY, United States, 11937 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-75
    17.5 km from Shelter Island

    The contemporary C/O The Maidstone is a great place in... More details

    From
    C$924
    per night
    Book Now
  • 226 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY, United States, 11937 (Map)
    8.4 - Exceptional
    Based on 3 reviews
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-70
    17.9 km from Shelter Island

    East Hampton House is a 3-star hotel offering a... More details

    From
    C$272
    per night
    Book Now
  • 371 Montauk Highway , Southampton, NY, United States (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-36
    18.2 km from Shelter Island

    White Fences Inn is a 4-star property only 3.8 km from... More details

    From
    C$666
    per night
    Book Now
  • 240 Big Fresh Pond Road, Southampton, Ny, Us, Southampton, NY, United States, 11968 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-25
    18.2 km from Shelter Island

    Charming Lakehouse In Southampton is located in a... More details

    Book Now
  • 534 North Magee Street , Southampton, NY, United States, 11968 (Map)
    •  pics,photos
    • 1-36
    18.8 km from Shelter Island

    Hamptons House Of Gardens is located in a cultural area... More details

    Book Now
  • Hotels near Shelter Island

    {{ hotel.name }}

    {{ hotel.stars }} star hotel
    {{ hotel.address }}, {{ hotel.city }}, {{ hotel.zip }} (Map)
    {{ hotel.mark / 5 | number : 1 }} - {{ hotel.mark_text }}
    Based on {{ hotel.reviews_count }} reviews
    • 1-{{ hotel.photo_count }} 
    {{ hotel.distanceDesc }}  |  {{ hotellist.amenitiesDesc }}

    {{ hotel.description }} More details

    From
    C${{ hotel.min_rate }}
    per night
    Not available
    Map goes here
    Checking available rooms...
    {{ conf.title }}
    {{ room.name }}
    Prepayment requiredNon-refundableDeposit requiredBook with no credit cardFree cancellation
    • {{rate.bedconf}}
    • {{rate.payathotel}}
    • {{rate.one_euro_deposit}}
    • {{rate.desc}}
    • Smoking
    • Non Smoking
    • Pay at hotel
    • {{rate.rate_id_desc}}
    • {{rate.view}}
    {{ rate.currency }} {{ rate.price }}
    for  night
    Change room
    Please select Room {{ conf_index + 1 }}
    {{ conf.title }}
    Room Type Conditions Rate Reservation
    {{ room.photos[room.current_photo].alt }}{{ room.photos[room.current_photo].alt }}

    {{ room.desc }}

    • {{amenity}}

    {{ room.info }}

    {{room.name}}{{ room.sqm }}m2
    {{room.photos[ room.current_photo ].name}}

    Included: {{ room.rates[0].included }}

    Not included: {{ room.rates[0].excluded }}

    Prepayment requiredNon-refundableDeposit requiredBook with no credit cardFree cancellation
    • {{rate.bedconf}}
    • {{rate.payathotel}}
    • {{rate.one_euro_deposit}}
    • {{rate.desc}}
    • Smoking
    • Non Smoking
    • Pay at hotel
    • {{rate.rate_id_desc}}
    • {{rate.view}}
    Show {{ room.rates.length - rooms.maxRates }} more rates
    Hide rates
    {{ rate.currency }} {{ rate.price }}
    for  night
    {{ conf.more_rooms_title }}

You can find more hotels by changing your search:

Remove all filters

Filtering results

Please wait...

^
25 hotels found

Your preferences

Star rating

  • ({{ star.count }})

Accommodation type

Price

per room per night
C$  – C$ OK

Location

Hotel type

  • MoreHide

Search by name

Property or hotel chain name

Amenities

  • More amenities

Room facilities

Services