Shelter Island NY Hotels

    • Sort by:
    • Popularity
    • Price
    • Star rating
    • Guest rating
Legend
Legend
  • Hotels on page
  •  
  • Other hotels
  • Airports
  • Underground stations
  • Train stations
  • Parks
  • Tourist attractions
  • Museums
  • Convention centers
  • Stadiums
  • Food and meals
  • General

Hover above the icons to see hotel photo and details.

Click the hotel to go to the main hotel page.

  • 35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11965, Map
    7.6
    Fabulous
    Based on 21 reviews
    Sunset Beach photos Exterior
    Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in rooms

    Free parking
    24-hour

    24-hour reception

    Sports activities

    Golf course

    Cycling

    Table tennis

    Spa and relaxation

    Reflex massage

    Sunset Beach Hotel is set in a seaside area of Shelter Island next to Bay Street Theatre, Mashomack Preserve and Railroad Museum of Long Island. Renovated in 2010, the unique hotel has welcomed guests since 1970. More details

    From
    C$673
    per night
    Not available
  • 81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11964, Map
    9.2
    Superb
    Based on 1 reviews
    The Pridwin Hotel photos Exterior
    Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in public areas

    Free parking
    Swimming pool

    Infinity pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

    Sports activities

    Tennis court

    Golf course

    Cycling

    Billiards/Pool tables

    Table tennis

    Spa and relaxation

    Reflex massage

    The 3-star The Pridwin Hotel lies within 3.5 km from Mashomack Preserve, Railroad Museum of Long Island and Montauk Point Lighthouse. More details

    From
    C$479
    per night
    Not available
  • 7 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, United States, 11965, Map
    Seven Shelter Island Guest House photos Exterior
    Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in rooms

    Free parking
    Check-in/Check-out

    Express check-in/-out

    Sports activities

    Tennis court

    Golf course

    Horseback riding

    Wind surfing

    Diving

    Fishing

    Cycling

    Hiking

    Mini golf

    Spa and relaxation

    Reflex massage

    The business 2-star Seven Shelter Island Guest House is a great place to stay in Shelter Island Heights. Seven Shelter Island Guest House has been welcoming guests to its non-smoking rooms since 1902. More details

    From
    C$358
    per night
    Not available

Filtering results

Please wait...

^
3 hotels found
Go to map view
Go to list view
Average rating
  • (1)
  • (1)
Hotel type
  • (1)
  • (1)
  • (1)
  • (1)
Search by name
Amenities
  • (3)
  • (2)
  • (2)
  • (2)
  • (2)
  • (2)
  • (2)
  • Show more
Room facilities
  • (1)
  • (3)
Services
  • (1)
  • (3)